*Tuesday hours: Open on the second and fourth Tuesdays of each month only.
In the 1930s, Staten Island restaurateur Al Deppe purchased the property. He installed a bar and transformed an enclosed porch into a cocktail lounge. According to lodge history, a tunnel once connected the house to Deppe's restaurant across the street, reportedly allowing him to transport the day's receipts home.
Staten Island Elks Lodge #841 purchased the property in 1960, establishing what would become the lodge's fifth home on Staten Island.
Article about BPO Elks #841 by Staten Island Advance