Try broadening your search criteria by supplying less information. For example, select a state from the drop down list and leave all other fields blank. Then scan the results list for the lodge you need.
Another hint: if you're searching by Lodge or city name, type only the most distinctive part of the name. For example, try “Arlington” instead of “Arlington Heights, IL”. That way you'll find the Lodge you're looking for even if you haven't supplied an exact match of the name as it exists in our database.